Heavy Cream

by Sarah Blakley-Cartwright

First published 2026

Geraldine has spent her life on the road with her unstable mother, learning to sneak into motel pools and scam restaurant meals instead of studying math. When her mother abandons her in New York City, sixteen-year-old Gerry finds herself passed between three women who each want to remake her. Bonnie, her mother's college friend, offers country club respectability and domestic comfort. Nell, her estranged aunt and successful artist, pushes ambition and reinvention. Finley, an old-money socialite, opens doors to Manhattan's elite circles. Each woman represents a different path, a different version of who Gerry could become. As she navigates these competing influences, Gerry must figure out which parts of herself to keep and which to shed. The novel follows her journey from a girl shaped by dysfunction and survival tactics to someone discovering her own identity amid the pull of three very different worlds.

Genres: literary-fiction, domestic-fiction, coming-of-age, contemporary, young-adult, family-drama

Vibes: character-driven, emotionally-complex, intimate, introspective, thought-provoking

Tropes: coming-of-age, found-family, identity-crisis, multiple-perspectives

Setting: New York City, Manhattan

Period: Contemporary

304 pages · Hardcover · Simon & Schuster

Content warnings: abuse

More by Sarah Blakley-Cartwright

Books like Heavy Cream

See all books like Heavy Cream

View on Siftivo