The Hardest Ones to Fool

by Christina Li

First published 2026

Amelia Wu has perfected the art of deception. She maintains three separate relationships with three different boys, presenting herself as Amy to the debate team captain, Ellie to the indie filmmaker, and Mia to the tennis star. Each boyfriend believes he has her complete devotion, while Amelia enjoys triple the expensive dinners, yacht trips, and gifts. Her system works flawlessly until her best friend is murdered, sending shockwaves through their quiet beachside town. The investigation threatens to expose Amelia's elaborate web of lies as her three relationships begin colliding in dangerous ways. Desperate to protect her secrets, Amelia forms an unlikely partnership with Jackie, her academic rival who edits the school newspaper and obsesses over true crime cases. Together they dig into the murder, but Amelia must navigate between keeping her boyfriends satisfied and her new ally close. Her survival depends on maintaining the very deceptions that could destroy her.

Genres: drama, mystery, crime, contemporary, thriller, young-adult

Vibes: dark, fast-paced, gritty, morally-complex, suspenseful, tension-filled

Tropes: enemies-to-allies, murder-mystery, secrets-and-lies, unreliable-narrator

Setting: beachside town

256 pages · Paperback · Penguin Workshop

Content warnings: murder

More by Christina Li

Books like The Hardest Ones to Fool

See all books like The Hardest Ones to Fool

View on Siftivo