The Wrong Good Deed

by Caroline B. Cooney

First published 2023

Christaphine is twenty and newly married to Tommy in 1964. She wants to build a life with her husband, but everything changes when she finds Tommy and his friends about to commit a terrible crime. She stops them, knowing this choice means she can never return home. So she vanishes completely. Fifty years pass. Clemmie sits in Sunday service at Trinity Hill Church when her neighbor Muffin pulls her away. Muffin has spotted a man across the aisle, someone she believes is connected to her dangerous past. Clemmie thinks Muffin is overreacting until Muffin tells her what really happened in that South Carolina field decades ago. The story reveals that Muffin has been hiding dark secrets all these years. Clemmie realizes she has secrets too. Both women understand that some truths carry consequences too severe to risk exposure.

Genres: fiction, drama, 20th-century, mystery, crime, contemporary

Vibes: dark, emotional, intimate, suspenseful, thought-provoking

Tropes: deception, secrets, unreliable-narrator

Setting: South Carolina, Trinity Hill Church

Period: 1964, Fifty years later

272 pages · Paperback · Poisoned Pen Press

Content warnings: violence

More by Caroline B. Cooney

Readers who liked The Wrong Good Deed also liked

View on Siftivo